Understanding the Rights of Transgender Individuals in India

Indian Courts and Transgender Identity

Indian courts have played a pivotal role in acknowledging the identity of transgender individuals and striving to grant them the fundamental human rights inherent to every citizen of India. A landmark judgment in this regard was the National Legal Services Authority (NALSA) v. Union of India case.

In this crucial 2014 ruling, the Supreme Court of India declared that fundamental rights must extend equally to the ‘third gender,’ just as they do to males and females. The Court specifically affirmed that transgender persons are protected under key articles of the Indian Constitution, including:

• Article 15: Prohibits discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex, or place of birth.
• Article 16: Guarantees equality of opportunity in matters of public employment.
• Article 21: Ensures the protection of life and personal liberty.

The Supreme Court emphasized that not identifying as male or female is neither a social nor a medical issue. Instead, it is a fundamental aspect of human identity that society is obligated to recognize. The Court unequivocally stated that the right to one’s gender identity is protected under Article 14 (Right to Equality) and Article 21 (Right to Life with Dignity), considering it an essential component of living a life with dignity, making personal choices, and privacy. This privacy aspect was further reinforced by the subsequent Puttaswamy judgment on the right to privacy.

The Court’s interpretation of Article 14 highlighted that its protection extends to “any person,” unequivocally including transgender individuals. Furthermore, it clarified that Articles 15 and 16 are not limited to biological sex but are intended to encompass those who identify as neither male nor female, thus recognizing the ‘third gender.’

Constitutional Safeguards for Transgender Rights

The NALSA judgment fundamentally reshaped the legal landscape for transgender individuals in India, ensuring their access to fundamental rights under the Constitution:

• Equality and Dignity: The judgment affirmed that transgender individuals possess fundamental rights under Articles 14, 15, 16, and 21. This means they are entitled to equality before the law, non-discrimination, and the right to live with dignity, including the right to choose their identity and privacy.
• Right to Education: Article 21A, which guarantees the right to education as a fundamental right, also extends to transgender individuals. The NALSA judgment explicitly affirmed their right to education, applicable to those who identify as a ‘third gender’ from a young age (six to fourteen years old).
• Inclusive Educational Environments: The Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, places a legal obligation on educational institutions to be inclusive towards transgender students and provide necessary facilities. The Madras High Court has also issued directives for educational institutions to offer gender-neutral restrooms and additional gender categories on official forms. However, the practical implementation of these guidelines at the grassroots level still faces challenges.
• Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019 (Ministry of Social Justice and Empowerment)

Navigating Inheritance Rights for Transgender Individuals

Inheritance rights remain a complex area for transgender individuals in India due to several factors:

• Gendered Inheritance Laws: Inheritance in India is largely governed by personal religious laws (like Hindu, Muslim, Christian laws), which often use gender-specific terminology (“male heir,” “female heir”). This creates ambiguity and difficulty for transgender persons to claim their rightful inheritance, as these laws traditionally recognize only two genders. Despite repeated representations to the Law Commission of India, comprehensive legislative reforms to address this issue are still pending.
• Identity Documentation: A significant hurdle is the lack of proper identification documents recognizing ‘third gender’ status. While legal recognition exists, acquiring official documents with a preferred third gender identity can be challenging. Without proper identification, asserting inheritance rights, especially for property and other assets, becomes difficult.
• Hindu Succession Act, 1956: This Act, which governs inheritance for Hindus, Buddhists, Jains, and Sikhs, primarily outlines succession rules for “males” and “females.” Sections like 8 (for male succession) and 15 (for female succession) do not explicitly mention provisions for transgender individuals. To avoid complications, transgender individuals sometimes identify as female for inheritance purposes, as the Act does not explicitly disqualify them.
• Muslim Personal Laws (Shariat): Muslim inheritance laws in India are uncodified and based on the Quran. They, too, are largely binary in their interpretation, making the position of transgender individuals regarding inheritance ambiguous and often unfavorable.
• Indian Succession Act: This Act applies to individuals who are not covered by Hindu, Muslim, Jain, Buddhist, or Sikh personal laws. While it uses seemingly gender-neutral terms like “kindred” and “lineal descendants,” the underlying framework often still operates within a binary understanding of gender, leaving a gap for the transgender community.
• The Role of Wills: A crucial way for transgender individuals to secure their inheritance rights is through a Will. A legally valid Will can explicitly outline how assets should be distributed, overriding standard intestate succession laws (inheritance without a Will). Wills are not gender-dependent and can include any person as a beneficiary, regardless of their gender identity.

Marital Rights for Transgender Individuals

The right to marry legally is often denied to transgender individuals, mirroring challenges faced by the LGBTQ+ community in general. This directly impacts inheritance rights, as many personal laws link inheritance to marital status.

• Challenges in Existing Laws: Personal marriage laws, such as the Hindu Marriage Act (HMA), traditionally use gender-specific terms like ‘bride’ and ‘bridegroom.’ The interpretation of these terms to include transgender persons has been a subject of debate.
• Madras High Court’s Progressive Ruling: In a significant 2019 judgment (Arun Kumar & Anr. v. Inspector General of Registration & Ors.), the Madras High Court boldly interpreted the word ‘bride’ in Section 5 of the HMA to include transgender persons. This decision was rooted in the principles of Article 21, the Puttaswamy judgment, and the NALSA judgment, affirming the right to marry for transgender individuals.
• Legislative Gaps: Despite this progressive judicial interpretation, the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, unfortunately, did not include specific provisions for the marriage of transgender persons. While the literal reading of the Act might not prohibit such marriages, the lack of explicit recognition often leads to practical difficulties and prohibition by authorities interpreting the law narrowly.
• Hindu Marriage Act (HMA) and Special Marriage Act (SMA):
  • The HMA defines “prohibited relationships” and primarily deals with heterosexual marriages. Its binary language creates hurdles for transgender marriages.
  • The Special Marriage Act (SMA), intended for secular, inter-faith marriages, also presents challenges. While designed to be more inclusive, its conditions for a valid marriage, such as “fit for procreation,” have historically been interpreted in a way that excludes transgender individuals.

Employment Rights for Transgender Individuals

The right to employment for transgender individuals is expressly protected by the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019. This legislation specifically prohibits discrimination against transgender persons in employment and related matters. Key provisions include:

• Prohibition of Unfair Treatment: Section 3(b) prohibits unfair treatment of a transgender person concerning employment or occupation.
• Non-Discriminatory Practices: Section 3(c) forbids denial or termination from employment, and Section 9 specifically prohibits discrimination in matters of employment, including recruitment, promotion, and other aspects.
• Employer Obligations: Section 10 of the Act mandates that establishments must strictly enforce these provisions and provide necessary facilities to transgender persons.
• Constitutional Safeguards: Beyond the specific Act, Articles 14 (Equality before Law) and 15 (Prohibition of Discrimination) of the Constitution also safeguard transgender individuals from employment discrimination, ensuring their right to equality in the workplace.

Recent Supreme Court Directives on Employment

In September 2022, the Supreme Court issued a significant directive to the Central Government, giving them three months to formulate a comprehensive policy to open up employment opportunities for transgender individuals, especially in sectors like aviation (prompted by a petitioner from that industry).

The Supreme Court underscored that the petitioner’s case raised broader issues concerning government policy formulation to ensure non-discrimination against transgender people. It explicitly ordered the Centre to comply with the provisions and spirit of the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, reiterating that no establishment, whether private or public, should discriminate against transgender individuals in employment matters.

The Court further directed the Department of Personnel & Training and the Social Justice Ministry to collaborate with the National Council for Transgender Persons (a body established under the 2019 Act) to consult and prepare a welfare and rights policy for the community.

Adoption Rights for Transgender Individuals

Adoption rights for transgender individuals in India currently face significant legal challenges:

• Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act: While this Act is generally gender-neutral in stating that “any person” can adopt, a crucial prerequisite for couples is formal recognition under Section 41(6). This poses a problem for transgender individuals, as their co-existence and marital status are often not legally recognized, making it impossible for them to be recognized as a ‘couple’ for adoption purposes.
• Hindu Adoption & Maintenance Act (HAMA): This Act, applicable to Hindus, explicitly recognizes adoptions only by either a “male” or a “female,” leaving no clear pathway for transgender individuals to adopt under its provisions.

The absence of explicit recognition of transgender individuals as adoptive parents in existing personal and secular laws creates a significant barrier to their right to form families through adoption.

FAQs

Q1: What was the significance of the NALSA judgment?

The NALSA v. Union of India judgment in 2014 was a landmark ruling by the Supreme Court of India that legally recognized transgender people as a “third gender” and affirmed that they are entitled to fundamental rights under the Indian Constitution, including equality, non-discrimination, and the right to dignity.

Q2: Is discrimination against transgender persons illegal in India?

Yes, the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, explicitly prohibits discrimination against transgender persons in various areas, including education, employment, healthcare, and access to public services.

Q3: Can transgender persons marry legally in India?

While a progressive Madras High Court judgment in 2019 affirmed the right of transgender persons to marry, the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, does not explicitly address marriage rights. This creates legal ambiguity and practical challenges in official recognition of transgender marriages under existing personal laws like the Hindu Marriage Act or the Special Marriage Act.

Q4: Do transgender individuals have the right to adopt children in India?

Currently, adoption laws in India, like the Juvenile Justice Act and the Hindu Adoption & Maintenance Act, present significant challenges for transgender individuals to adopt, especially if they are not recognized as a formally married couple under existing binary laws.

Q5: What is the National Council for Transgender Persons?

The National Council for Transgender Persons is a body established under the Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019, to advise the Central Government on policies, programs, legislation, and projects concerning transgender persons, as well as to monitor the impact of these policies.

Conclusion

India has made significant strides in acknowledging the rights and existence of the transgender community, particularly through the groundbreaking NALSA judgment and the subsequent Transgender Persons (Protection of Rights) Act, 2019. These legal frameworks aim to safeguard their fundamental human rights, promote equality, and prohibit discrimination in various spheres of life, including education and employment.

However, despite these crucial advancements, the journey towards full equality and inclusion is ongoing. Challenges persist, particularly concerning inheritance, marriage, and adoption rights, which are deeply intertwined with existing gender-binary legal provisions. The lack of comprehensive implementation of existing guidelines at the grassroots level also remains a concern.

The continued focus from the judiciary, coupled with the commitment to further legislative reforms and effective implementation of welfare policies, will be crucial in ensuring that transgender individuals in India can truly live with dignity, equality, and enjoy all the rights afforded to every citizen. It’s a collective responsibility to build a society where gender identity is respected and celebrated, leading to genuine social justice for all.

For legal assistance, call +91 9461620006 or visit www.bestdivorcelawyer.in today.